Rapid expansion of natural rubber plantations in South-East Asia and other regions has greatly altered ecosystem based carbon (C) stocks with potential impacts on climate change mitigation and future C trading opportunities. Therefore, reliable estimations of carbon sequestration and emission at the landscape level after land cover transition from forest, swidden agriculture and other land use types are needed. We reviewed studies on C stocks and dynamics in rubber plantations considering the contribution of aboveground and belowground biomass, soil organic matter, collected latex and other minor components. C sequestration occurred after conversion of arable land to rubber plantations while C losses usually prevailed if forest was converted to rubber. These general trends strongly depended on local climate conditions and soil properties as well as on topography. Non-traditional planting of rubber under subtropical conditions with a dryer climate and at high elevations (300–1000 m above sea level) decreased the C sequestration potential of rubber. We show how rotation length, rubber clone, and management strategies like tapping frequency or planting density affect C stocks, discuss the uncertainties in C stock estimation and highlight improved approaches. An important conclusion is that upscaling of C stocks and dynamics under different climate scenarios and rotation lengths to a regional level requires the use of time averaged C stocks. Enhanced remote sensing techniques can greatly improve C stock estimates at the regional level, allowing for an accounting of the variability caused by terrain and plantation properties. A partial life cycle assessment of rubber production revealed greenhouse gas emissions as a minor contribution when compared to land use change effects on plant and soil C stocks and C accumulation in latex, wood products and seed oil. The review highlights scantily explored topics and proposes directions for future studies, which should decrease uncertainties in C estimates in rubber dominated landscapes.
Tag: Agroforestry systems
Ant-mediated ecosystem services and disservices on marketable yield in cocoa agroforestry systems
The impact of complex direct and indirect interactions between multiple functional groups on plants is poorly documented. In tropical agroecosystems, ants interact with crop mutualists and antagonists, however, little is known about effects of dominants ant community properties on the consequence of such cascading interactions which can be measured through final ecosystem service, crop yield. Here, we present a replicated ant fauna manipulation experiment in cocoa agroecosystems, where we used ant exclusion treatments to test the economic importance of the presence of ants, and two additional treatments where we experimentally introduced one of two common dominant ant species which allowed comparing their effects with those of the naturally occurring ant fauna. The proximate aim was to assess the impact of ants Crematogaster sp., Camponotus brutus Auguste-Henri Forel and Oecophylla longinoda Latreille on cacao yield, which is known to depend on several, cascading intermediate ecosystem services (e.g. control of specific pests). Ants provided ecosystem services in term of reduced pest damage caused by Salhbergella singularis Hagh (Hemiptera: Miridae) and Characoma stictigrapta Hmps (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) but also disservices such as increased pathogen disease caused by Phyphthora megakarya Brasier and Griffin dissemination and indirectly enhanced damage of other pest species. Yields were highest in non-manipulated and species-rich ant communities, whereas ant exclusion and communities dominated by a single species decreased yield by more than 30%. Associated ant communities between dominant and non-dominant species resulted in the same yields as in non-manipulated controls. Dominant ant communities maximized the control of a particular pest species, but not cacao yield. We show a positive relationship between ant species rich communities and financial performance and we postulate that complex agroecosystems can offer competitive business opportunities for small-scale farmers, while contributing to biodiversity conservation. However, more interdisciplinary studies are needed to quantify financial and biodiversity performance opportunities to allow up-scaling of these findings. © 2017 Elsevier B.V.
Competition for light in heterogeneous canopies: Application of MAESTRA to a coffee (Coffea arabica L.) agroforestry system
In agroforestry systems (AFS), quantifying the competition for light is a prerequisite toward understanding the impact of shade trees on the productivity of the under-cropModels for homogeneous canopies and shade/full-sun approaches do not address the intra-plot heterogeneity, typical of AFS. For the first time, MAESTRA, a 3D light absorption model, was fully parameterized in a heterogeneous 2-canopy layers AFS. We quantified competition for photosynthetic photon flux density (Q) between shade trees (Erythrina poepiggiana) and coffee (Coffea arabica), with a spatial resolution from the plant to the plot (2.7 ha) and a temporal resolution from half-hour to one full year. The predicted transmittance through the 2-canopy layers was verified against field measurements. The goodness of fit (R2 > 0.75, RRMSE < 26%) was comparable to the predictions from 10 other studies using 3D light models and mostly verified in one-layered systems (mean R2 = 0.89 and mean RRMSE = 17%). Maps of absorbed Q showed that despite their low density in the plot (5.2 trees ha-1), the tall Erythrina trees reduced Q available for the coffee layer by 14% annually. Annual pruning of the oldest unproductive coffee resprouts maintained a large horizontal heterogeneity in coffee LAI, with direct impact on the Q absorption mapThis management practice had a strong impact on seasonal variations of absorbed Q by the coffee canopy. We proposed also a simple approach to estimate Q absorbed yearly by the coffee plants in AFS of variable tree density, requiring only few measurements in the field. An extrapolation indicated that the amount of Q absorbed by the coffee canopy would display a negative exponential relationship (k = -0.34) when increasing shade tree density (from nil to 29 trees ha-1). The estimated k was similar to the shade tree extinction coefficient of diffuse radiation measured with a plant canopy analyzer. We showed that the presence of shade trees tends to reverse the diurnal time course of the fraction of Qa when compared to a plantation in the open. Overall, MAESTRA proved to successfully unlock the question of intra-plot heterogeneity for light absorption and to provide defensible light budgets as a continuous and mapped covariable, a crucial step for many field experimentations.
Light interception and evaporation in hedgerow agroforestry systems
Quantifying water lost through evaporation and transpiration in a cropping system is an important tool in adapting a system for semi-arid conditions. During two cropping seasons in eastern Kenya, light interception and soil water content were measured in several different cropping systems: monocultures of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.), maize (Zea mays cv. Katumani), Senna spectabilis cv. Embu managed as a hedge, and hedge intercrops of cowpea and maize. These systems differed with respect to plant population density, maximum light interception (44–75%) and canopy height (0.5–2.0 m). Parameters in the EPIC model for leaf area development were derived from periodically-measured light interception in the different systems. Daily light interception predicted from the leaf area was used to partition potential evapotranspiration into potential evaporation and potential transpiration. A simple water balance model was used to predict actual transpiration and actual soil evaporation. Predicted values of water loss during the two seasons correlated closely with measured values (r2 = 0.85 and 0.91; slope = 1.00 and 1.01). In both seasons, the model predicted that soil evaporation comprised approximately half (42–58%) of the estimated evapotranspiration. This study suggests that evapotranspiration can be predicted for a variety of cropping systems when light interception measurements are used in conjunction with a simple model of plant water uptake. It also demonstrates the difficulty of maximizing plant water use in agroforestry systems in semi-arid environments when the canopies of both annual crops and hedges develop simultaneously.
Modelling soil evaporation in an agroforestry system in Kenya
Soil evaporation measurements from bare soil and shaded soil under an agroforestry tree canopy were used to construct a model to predict soil evaporation with and without tree shade. It was found that a simple daily time step model based on the Ritchie (1972)approach was unable to predict daily soil evaporation accurately, but was capable of providing good estimates of cumulative soil evaporation over hydrologically significant periods (weeks–months). This model was used to show how trees could reduce annual soil evaporation directly beneath their canopy by an average of 35% (compared to completely bare soil), equivalent to 21% of rainfall. In sparse agroforestry tree canopies the area average saving is smaller, depending on tree leaf area index (LAI). The model also demonstrated how annual saving in soil evaporation due to a tree canopy might vary with rainfall, with a maximum of around 180 mm being achieved once rainfall exceeded 1000 mm year1. This saving in soil water is very significant and will help offset the enhanced evaporative losses associated with tree canopies due to interception and re-evaporation of rainfall or as tree transpiration
Understorey microclimate and crop performance in a Grevillea robusta-based agroforestry system in semi-arid Kenya
The influence of dispersed trees on microclimatic conditions, gas exchange and productivity of maize (Zea mays L.) in a Grevillea robusta-based agroforestry system in semi-arid Kenya was examined to test the hypothesis that the benefits of shade seen in savannah ecosystems may be outweighed by competition for below-ground resources. Meristem temperature, cumulative thermal time, intercepted radiation, spatial distribution of shade and gas exchange were determined for maize grown as sole crops, in an agroforestry system, or under shade nets providing 25 or 50% reductions in incident radiation to discriminate between effects of shade and below-ground competition. The major benefit of shade was to reduce exposure to the supra-optimal temperatures experienced in many tropical regions, and which are predicted to become increasingly common by climate change models. However, although trees decreased photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) incident on understorey maize by ca. 30%, the yield reduction was much greater than in the 25% shade net treatment in four seasons providing contrasting rainfall. Maize yield was unaffected by 50% artificial shade in the driest season (168 mm) but decreased with increasing shade when rainfall was high (628 mm). Shade reduced meristem temperature and delayed flowering by 5-24 days depending on treatment and seasonal rainfall. Thermal time to flowering in the agroforestry system doubled from 600 to 1200 C day as rainfall decreased. Photosynthetic and transpiration rates for understorey maize were similar to the 25 and 50% shade treatments when rainfall was high, but were ca. 10% of those for unshaded sole maize in dry seasons. PPFD-saturated photosynthetic rate was initially similar in all treatments but fell sharply in the agroforestry system as the season progressed. Radiation conversion coefficients did not differ between unshaded sole and understorey maize. The results suggest that the ameliorative influence of tree shade was greater in low rainfall seasons, as in savannah systems, but that potential benefits were outweighed by below-ground competition. This may be managed by root-pruning trees.
Allanblackia: bilingual monthly newsletter – ICRAF West & Central Africa Region – September
Each Electoral Col- lege had three can- didates competing and the exercise brought staff from ICRAF offices in Nkolbisson and Bamenda. To ensure the smooth run- ning of the exercise, two labour inspectors, Madam Messobot Emma and Mr Sama Ivo both of the Centre Provincial Delegation of Labour and Social security were on hand to supervise and to make sure the labour rules are respected. The rule of the game was explained to all the candidates and the other staff present. Those who were less than six months old in ICRAF could not vote because the labour law in Cameroon say so
Allanblackia: bilingual monthly newsletter – ICRAF West & Central Africa Region – September
Each Electoral Col- lege had three can- didates competing and the exercise brought staff from ICRAF offices in Nkolbisson and Bamenda. To ensure the smooth run- ning of the exercise, two labour inspectors, Madam Messobot Emma and Mr Sama Ivo both of the Centre Provincial Delegation of Labour and Social security were on hand to supervise and to make sure the labour rules are respected. The rule of the game was explained to all the candidates and the other staff present. Those who were less than six months old in ICRAF could not vote because the labour law in Cameroon say so
Modelling Agricultural Realities to Support Development Decisions
Most agricultural models do not adequately represent real-life development decisions, not least because they fail to consider the impact of the full range of biophysical, socioeconomic, political and cultural factors that affect decision outcomes. Many modelling exercises restrict their scope to system aspects that can be characterised with precision, but this can lead to biased recommendations. For instance, only considering annual crop yields while neglecting ecosystem services provided by trees systematically undervalues agroforestry systems. Similarly, crop models that only consider abiotic factors but leave out pests, weeds and diseases may favour crop varieties that fit poorly in smallholder farming systems. To produce more holistic assessments that respond to the needs of development decision-makers, agricultural modelling needs new strategies that enhance its ability to deal with real-world complexities and allow capturing system aspects that defy precise quantification.Decision analysis, a decision-support approach from the private sector, aims to make recommendations for specific decisions based on currently available knowledge. To gain a holistic perspective, it starts with an assessment — often involving decision-makers, stakeholders and experts — of all decision-relevant aspects and their interconnections. Results from this assessment are translated into causal decision models, in which all factors are considered in quantitative terms, represented using probability distributions. For each input variable, all available sources of information, including hard data and expert opinion, are used to construct the distributions. Simulations produce probability distributions expressing the range of plausible decision outcomes. These outputs are often sufficient for identifying preferable decision options. If not, tools such as Value of Information analysis are used to highlight critical knowledge gaps where further information is needed to reduce uncertainty and clarify the best decision alternative. Decision analysis approaches are new to agricultural research for development, but several successful applications across Africa, e.g. forecasting the impacts of agricultural interventions in Kenya or prioritising among strategies for reservoir protection in Burkina Faso, have underscored their potential. Experiences so far indicate that decision analysis could emerge as a new paradigm for holistic, decision-focused agricultural modelling.
Structural root form and fine root distribution of some woody species evaluated for agroforestry systems
Fine root distribution and structural root characteristics of four-years-old multipurpose woody species with potential for use in agroforestry systems were investigated on an Alfisol in the forest savanna transition zone of south-western Nigeria. Rooting patterns of woody species studied differed considerably. Lonchocarpus sericeus had the lowest percentage (21%) of total fine roots confined to the upper (0 to 30 cm) soil layer, compared to 84% with Tetrapleura tetraptera. Despite the superior tap root system of Enterolobium cyclocarpum and the fine root form of Nauchlea latifolia however, their extensive distribution and very large lateral woody root volume density may pose a major problem for seedbed preparation and tillage operations in simultaneous agroforestry systems. Lonchocarpus sericeus appears to have the most desirable structural and fine root architecture among the species studied for simultaneous agroforestry systems. The total root density below the underlying distal soil layers was linearly related to the sum of square of tap root diameter and the corresponding soil depths.